This was the 10th tour covering England in Australia and, quite comfortably, the most disappointing. Record numbers of people came to watch, showing the huge interest, but instead of a gripping contest, the series ended as a major let-down.
England faced what was effectively an Australia second XI, won four of the five tosses and still lost 4-1. The fifth Test defeat in Sydney confirmed another failed tour, leaving the team under heavy scrutiny.
Preparation blamed for failure
The turning point came on 24 July 2025, when England announced minimal pre-series preparation – just net sessions and one intra-squad warm-up. It was clear then that this was not enough to win an Ashes series in Australia.
The decision being signed off by the England and Wales Cricket Board has drawn strong criticism. Whoever approved it, whether senior officials or administrators, must be held accountable. England fans, many of whom spent their life savings to travel, are not just disappointed – they are angry.
Lack of discipline exposed
Supporters witnessed soft dismissals and dropped catches from an ill-disciplined side. In contrast, Australia were sharp in the field, relentless with the ball and produced big individual scores. The difference in standards was clear throughout the series.
McCullum’s methods questioned
Brendon McCullum is expected to be given the chance to turn things around, but doubts remain over whether he will change his approach. His relaxed style, successful in the past, has not worked with this group in Test cricket.
Bazball has unsettled players such as Ollie Pope, Harry Brook, Jamie Smith and Gus Atkinson. There needs to be more flexibility, more competitive cricket and a stronger focus on county cricket for player development.
Stokes must stay as captain
One constant England must keep is Ben Stokes as captain. While his tactical_attach mistakes were visible – including questionable field placements and bowling decisions – he remains the best leader available.
However, Harry Brook has shown he is not ready to lead. His irresponsible batting and lack of learning are worrying. Without reflection, he risks falling short of his potential.
Key selection calls ahead
England should not give up on Pope, who remains a talented batter. But the team must move on from Will Jacks as a frontline spinner, as he is not effective enough in that role.
Wicketkeeping is another concern. Jamie Smith’s poor tour, with just 211 runs in 10 innings and dropped catches, raises serious questions about who should keep wicket next summer.
Few positives from the tour
The only players to leave with credit are Josh Tongue and Jacob Bethell. Tongue impressed with his commitment, while Bethell’s 154 in Sydney looked like the innings of a seasoned Test player.
Brydon Carse was misused as an opening bowler but deserves praise for his effort across five Tests. Bethell’s approach is something Brook should study when learning how to construct a proper Test innings.
England now owe their supporters honest answers and meaningful changes to avoid repeating the same mistakes.
Discussion about this post