Manchester, UK – The fifth and final day of the fourth Test between England and India at Old Trafford culminated in a dramatic draw, but not before an unusual and much-debated incident involving England captain Ben Stokes and Indian batsmen Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar. As the match meandered towards an inevitable stalemate with India batting strongly, Stokes approached the Indian duo with an offer to shake hands and end the game early, a gesture that was surprisingly declined, sparking significant discussion in the cricketing world.
The Incident: A Captain’s Offer and a Batsmen’s Refusal
With approximately 90 minutes of play remaining on Day 5 and India having battled remarkably from 0/2 in their second innings to a commanding position of 386 for 4, leading by 75 runs, England’s bowlers were visibly fatigued. Sensing the inevitability of a draw and likely looking to preserve his frontline bowlers ahead of a swift turnaround for the final Test, Ben Stokes walked up to Ravindra Jadeja (then on 89*) and Washington Sundar (on 80*) during a break, extending a handshake to signify a mutual agreement to call off the match.
However, to Stokes’s visible surprise and apparent bewilderment, both Indian batters respectfully declined the offer. Sources indicate that both Jadeja and Sundar were keenly eyeing personal milestones – their respective centuries – and saw no tactical disadvantage in continuing to bat with no real threat from the weary English attack.
The Aftermath: Frustration, Sarcasm, and Milestones
Stokes’s initial reaction, caught on camera, was a mix of disbelief and frustration as he shook his head and walked back to his team. The moment quickly went viral, igniting debate among pundits and fans alike. England players, including Zak Crawley and Ben Duckett, were seen inquiring about India’s decision to bat on. At one point, Stokes himself was heard sarcastically asking Jadeja, “Do you want to score a hundred against Harry Brook?”
In a unique turn, Stokes responded to the refusal by bringing on part-time spinner Harry Brook to bowl. In a poetic twist, Jadeja capitalized immediately, smashing Brook for a six to bring up his third Test century. Just 15 balls later, Washington Sundar also reached his maiden Test hundred, also off Brook’s bowling. Once both milestones were achieved, the teams finally shook hands, and the match officially concluded in a hard-fought draw.
Right vs. Wrong: Perspectives on Sportsmanship and Strategy
The incident sparked a debate on the “spirit of cricket” versus individual milestones and strategic intent.
- Ben Stokes’s Perspective: Stokes later explained his decision was rooted in practicality and player welfare. With a draw inevitable, he stated he “wasn’t going to be risking any of my frontline bowlers in a situation like that, especially when we’ve got a quick turnaround” before the final Test. For a team under the Stokes-McCullum era that prioritizes aggressive play and rarely draws (this being only their second in 40 Tests), the situation was unusual.
- India’s Perspective: India’s captain Shubman Gill firmly backed his batters, stating, “It was up to the boys, but we felt they batted brilliantly. Both of them were in their 90s, and we believed they deserved to get to their centuries.” Former England captain Alastair Cook also sided with India, acknowledging the importance of personal milestones and the momentum gained from such a resilient fight.
- The Debate: Critics of India’s refusal, like Jonathan Trott, argued that “personal milestones” shouldn’t override an inevitable result in Test cricket. However, others, like Sanjay Manjrekar, criticized Stokes’s “spoiled kid” behavior, suggesting that throwing in a part-timer in protest was unnecessary given India’s right to bat on.
Ultimately, the draw, forged by heroic centuries from Shubman Gill, Ravindra Jadeja, and Washington Sundar after India were 0/2, ensured the series remains alive at 2-1 in England’s favour, setting the stage for a cracking finale at The Oval. The Old Trafford “handshake” will undoubtedly be a memorable talking point of the series for years to come.
Discussion about this post