England captain Ben Stokes said there would have been “hell on” if the Melbourne pitch used for the fourth Ashes Test had been prepared anywhere else in the world, after the match ended inside two days.
The surface at the Melbourne Cricket Ground had around 10mm of grass, leading to 36 wickets falling across six sessions. No batter from either side managed a half-century, with Travis Head’s 46 the highest individual score of the match.
Pitch under scrutiny after rapid finish
Asked about the feedback he would give to the match referee, Stokes was blunt about the conditions and suggested the game was not ideal for a five-day Test. He felt the nature of the contest would have drawn far heavier criticism had it occurred outside Australia.
According to BBC Sport, Stokes said: “With 36 wickets in less than two days and no total over 200, I think you can read into that a lot. If that was another condition somewhere else and that happened, you probably would get a pasting.”
England still managed to chase down a target of 175 to secure a four-wicket win, ending a run of 18 Tests without victory in Australia. The result also ensured Australia could not complete a 5-0 Ashes clean sweep, despite having already retained the urn.
Players and experts react to surface
Australia’s stand-in captain Steve Smith admitted the pitch had done more than expected, describing it as “furry and green” before the game. He suggested a slight reduction in grass might have created a more balanced contest.
According to BBC Sport, Smith said groundsmen were “always looking for the right balance” and would likely take lessons from the outcome.
Former England captain Michael Vaughan was more critical, labelling the contest unfair after day one and claiming the pitch had favoured bowlers excessively. The ICC will now assess the surface, which is rated after every international match.
Contrast with previous MCG Tests
The controversy contrasts sharply with the 2017 Ashes Test at the same venue, when the pitch was rated “poor” for being too batting-friendly after only 24 wickets fell in five days. On this occasion, England batter Joe Root described conditions as challenging but stopped short of calling them unfair.
According to BBC Sport, Root said: “You have a world-class attack and the ball is moving a considerable amount. Your job is to get on the right side of the result.”
Discussion about this post