Shohei Ohtani’s NLCS Game 4: Historic or Greatest Ever? And Who Will Take the World Series?

Los Angeles Dodgers superstar Shohei Ohtani left fans and analysts stunned in Game 4 of the NLCS, hitting three home runs and pitching six scoreless innings with 10 strikeouts. Naturally, this sparked debate: was it the greatest postseason performance ever?

Ohtani is the first pitcher in MLB history to hit three homers in a playoff game while also dominating on the mound. Only nine other pitchers have matched his pitching line of six innings, two hits, zero runs, and at least 10 strikeouts in postseason history.

Historic vs. Greatest

Sports analyst Neil Paine notes that while statistically some batters or pitchers have posted higher single-game contributions, Ohtani’s feat is unmatched because he did both simultaneously. By Run Expectancy Added, Ohtani scored +5.16, outpacing even Babe Ruth’s best combined pitching/ hitting playoff game (+4.01).

“It’s one of a kind. He didn’t just perform — he rewrote what we think is possible,” Paine said.

Harry Enten adds, “Historic is the right word. It may not be the ‘greatest’ in pure statistical terms, but it is truly unprecedented.”

The ‘Ohtanic’ Effect

Ohtani has forced baseball analysts to rethink how performance is measured. Doug Glanville famously called it ‘Ohtanic’ — a phenomenon not seen in modern baseball. Beyond stats, Ohtani has drawn massive international attention, particularly from Japanese fans, nearly doubling World Series viewership despite time differences.

The Dodgers have built a pipeline of talent from Japan, making them a global powerhouse and turning Ohtani’s unique skills into a branding revolution.

World Series Outlook: Dodgers vs. Blue Jays

With Toronto facing Los Angeles, the Fall Classic feels more international than ever. Despite the Blue Jays’ offensive firepower, led by Vladimir Guerrero Jr., the Dodgers’ depth is daunting.

• LA’s starters were historically dominant in the NLCS, including near-record rest heading into the series.

• Toronto averages 6.5 runs per game in the postseason, but will need pitching to contain Ohtani, Freddie Freeman, Mookie Betts, and other clutch hitters.

Neil Paine predicts the Dodgers will likely win in 5 games, though the Blue Jays’ potent lineup keeps them in contention.

Why Ohtani Matters Beyond Numbers

Even with a below-.200 batting average prior to Game 4, Ohtani dominated when it mattered most. His unique two-way skill set, combined with global appeal, makes him a transformative figure for MLB.

In short: Ohtani didn’t just play a great game — he expanded what’s possible in baseball and set the stage for a truly international World Series showdown.

Key Stat: Ohtani is the first pitcher in MLB postseason history to hit three home runs and strike out 10 in six shutout innings in a single game.